The claim and the lease
Imagine this scenario.
A tenant returns home after collecting his mail. His normal entrance is locked, so he walks across a common area of the apartment complex to reach an alternate entrance. Along the way, he steps into a hidden depression in the lawn, falls violently to the ground, and suffers significant injuries.
The tenant later discovers something troubling: not only had the dangerous condition existed for some time, but residents had reportedly complained about similar maintenance issues on the property before.
The claim seems straightforward, right?
Not so fast.
When the injury claim was presented to the property owner's insurance carrier, the adjuster immediately shifted focus away from the dangerous condition and onto the tenant's lease agreement.
The adjuster pointed to provisions requiring the tenant to maintain renter's insurance, assume certain risks, indemnify the landlord, and waive claims against the property owner—even for the landlord's own negligence.
For many injured tenants, that would sound like the end of the road.
Fortunately, California law says otherwise.
The Tactic: Shift the Focus Away From the Dangerous Condition
One of the most common strategies in premises liability claims is to redirect attention away from the hazardous condition that caused the injury.
Instead of asking:
Was there a dangerous condition?
Did the landlord know about it?
Should the landlord have repaired it?
Did the condition cause the injury?
The discussion suddenly becomes:
Did the tenant buy renter's insurance?
Did the tenant sign a waiver?
Did the tenant assume the risk?
Did the tenant agree to indemnify the landlord?
These questions may sound important, but they often have little or no impact on whether the landlord is actually liable.
California Does Not Permit Residential Landlords to Contract Away Their Duty of Care
California Civil Code section 1953 provides that residential tenants cannot waive certain fundamental rights, including:
The right to bring future claims against a landlord; and
The right to have the landlord exercise reasonable care to prevent personal injury.
In other words, a residential landlord generally cannot insert language into a lease that says:
"You cannot sue us if we negligently maintain the property."
California courts have repeatedly held that such provisions are void as against public policy.
This makes sense.
Housing is not a luxury. It is a necessity. Tenants rarely negotiate lease language and often sign standardized agreements drafted entirely by landlords or property management companies.
California law recognizes this imbalance and protects tenants accordingly.
The California Supreme Court Already Addressed This Issue
Nearly fifty years ago, the California Supreme Court decided Henrioulle v. Marin Ventures, Inc.
In that case, a tenant was injured in a common area of an apartment complex. The lease contained broad language attempting to shield the landlord from liability.
The Supreme Court refused to enforce the provision.
The Court recognized that residential housing affects the public interest and held that landlords cannot use lease provisions to escape responsibility for their own negligence.
The lesson remains the same today:
A lease is not a magic shield against liability.
What About the Tenant's Failure to Obtain Renter's Insurance?
Another common argument is that the tenant failed to maintain renter's insurance as required by the lease.
This argument sounds persuasive until one asks a simple question:
What does the tenant's insurance have to do with the landlord's negligence?
The answer is usually: very little.
A tenant's renter's insurance may protect the tenant's personal property or provide liability coverage for damages caused by the tenant.
It does not eliminate the landlord's independent duty to maintain common areas in a reasonably safe condition.
California courts have long recognized that a landlord's duty of care exists independently of whatever insurance a tenant may or may not have purchased.
The absence of renter's insurance does not transform a dangerous condition into a safe one.
Common Areas Matter
The distinction between common areas and private living spaces is critical.
When a landlord retains ownership, possession, and control over common areas—such as lawns, walkways, stairways, corridors, parking lots, and entrances—the landlord generally remains responsible for maintaining those areas in a reasonably safe condition.
That responsibility cannot simply be delegated away through boilerplate lease language.
If a dangerous condition exists in a common area and the landlord knew or should have known about it, liability may follow regardless of what the lease says.
The Real Questions
In many premises liability cases, the most important questions are surprisingly simple:
Who controlled the area where the incident occurred?
Was the condition dangerous?
How long had it existed?
Did the landlord have actual or constructive notice?
Was the condition repaired?
Did the dangerous condition cause the injury?
Those are the questions that determine liability.
Not whether a tenant checked a box on an insurance application years earlier.
A Lesson for Injured Tenants and Attorneys
Insurance adjusters are doing their jobs when they investigate every possible defense.
However, injured tenants and their attorneys should be careful not to assume that every lease provision is enforceable simply because it appears in writing.
Many lease provisions are enforceable.
Some are not.
When a residential landlord attempts to rely on waivers, indemnity provisions, or insurance requirements to avoid responsibility for dangerous conditions in common areas, those provisions should be carefully scrutinized under California law before being accepted at face value.
The existence of a lease does not eliminate a landlord's duty to act reasonably.
And it certainly does not give a landlord permission to ignore dangerous conditions that place tenants at risk.
General information, not legal advice about a particular matter. Reading this article or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Back to all insights ↗